This piece was originally published on LinkedIn on November 3, 2024. Since then, the conversation around AI and media has only intensified, with AI-generated influencers, interactive AI-driven entertainment, and platforms continuing to push the boundaries of digital performance. The parallels to vaudeville continue to resonate for me—just as variety acts once captivated audiences, today’s AI-powered creators (whether they are a vidtuber, an influencer, or even a podcaster) are reshaping what it means to perform, engage, and entertain. As continue to figure out Substack, I’d love to hear your thoughts. I will continue to move older content over daily for the next few weeks, then settle into a rhythm. At a minimum I’ll likely have at least one new piece per week to reflect on what I’m seeing and who I’m talking to.
thanks, AB.
As published on Linkedin.com:
Before diving into this article, I have to acknowledge that I’ve probably sat on this idea longer than any other project. This piece is, in many ways, the culmination of conversations I had back when I worked at Magnet Media, Inc in New York City around 2005 or 2006 (hi, Megan Cunningham!). YouTube had just launched, and it was the only thing anyone in online media could talk about. Some people didn’t get it; others thought it would change everything. By late 2006, when Google bought YouTube, it became clear that this platform would become a cornerstone of media technology for the next decade and beyond.
At Magnet, as we watched this unfolding, I couldn’t help but draw connections to the past. My first thought when I saw YouTube was of vaudeville: the short, varied performances and the curated experience for audiences. It felt like history was repeating itself, just in a digital format. Little did I know, this would blossom into an entire culture of creators and influencers, echoing that vaudevillian spirit of captivating an audience with diverse content.
So, as I push myself to write more about the intersection of AI and media, I realized it was time to finally check this box—a nearly 20-year-old task I’ve talked about but never truly articulated until now.
Introduction
Imagine stepping into a vaudeville theater in the heart of a bustling American city at the turn of the 20th century—perhaps in New York, Chicago, or Philadelphia. The streets outside are lively, not with the roar of car engines but with horse-drawn carriages, trolleys, and people weaving between street vendors and the occasional automobile, a luxury for the wealthy. Inside their homes, those fortunate enough to have electricity enjoy a dim glow from fixtures designed to resemble gas lamps. While some families may have heard of the invention of the radio, actually owning one is a rarity reserved for the affluent.
For many, the vaudeville theater is a precious escape from long days of factory work or labor-intensive chores. The acts are as diverse as the audience: slapstick comedians, acrobats, magicians, singers, and sultry burlesque dancers who save their performances for late-night crowds. Vaudeville offered something for everyone, a luxury of variety in a world with limited entertainment options.
Fast forward to 2005, and YouTube emerges, bringing that same spirit of variety and unpredictability into the digital age. It began as a simple solution to a straightforward problem: making video content easy to share online. But what it became was far more complex and culturally significant—a digital vaudeville, curated and customized by both contributors and algorithms, driven by our timeless desire for diverse, engaging content.
This isn’t just a technological story; it’s a cultural one. Understanding platforms like YouTube—and even AI—requires a look through the lens of cultural determinism, a perspective arguing that societal patterns shape how technologies are developed, adopted, and integrated. The evolution from vaudeville to YouTube—and now the role of AI—illustrates that history doesn’t repeat itself but evolves in response to enduring cultural needs.
Cultural Determinism
With the stage set—literally and metaphorically—let’s explore cultural determinism, the idea that technology evolves to meet societal needs, not the other way around. Cultural theorist Raymond Williams famously said, “culture is ordinary,” meaning it shapes everything around us, including technology. Unlike the concept of technological determinism, which suggests technology independently drives societal change, cultural determinism insists that our cultural practices influence technological advancements.
Think about it this way: Have you ever noticed how technological tools that seem groundbreaking often reflect existing cultural habits or desires? That's cultural determinism at work.
Applying this to media, the shift from vaudeville to YouTube isn’t as revolutionary as it seems. Vaudeville responded to a societal desire for diverse, consumable entertainment, offering acts that reflected the pace and energy of urban life. Early cinema in the U.S. even began as nickelodeons—short films in makeshift theaters, mirroring vaudeville’s format. It took the influence of French cinema, with its emphasis on longer-form narratives and star-studded events, to shape what we now think of as modern movies.
AI fits into this pattern, too. Today, algorithms tailor content to our preferences, but they’re just the latest iteration of the audience engagement strategies that have always existed. We crave personalized experiences, and AI has adapted to meet that demand. Rather than a disruption, AI’s role is part of an ongoing story where technology evolves to fulfill human needs.
Historical Continuity and Technological Shifts
Vaudeville was more than just entertainment; it was a cultural response to the social fabric of early 20th-century America. Stages offered a melting pot of acts that mirrored society’s diversity, from slapstick to burlesque. But even vaudeville had roots in earlier traveling troupes and circuses, showing that entertainment has always evolved to meet cultural demands. Media historian Lisa Gitelman emphasizes how the materiality of media and cultural expectations shape what gets produced, setting the stage for future formats.
As technology evolved, the variety format of vaudeville didn’t disappear; it adapted. Radio and TV sanitized the content to fit broader societal norms, giving us family-friendly programming that still echoed vaudeville’s diversity. Media scholar Amanda Lotz explains how new formats continue to serve fragmented audience needs, reflecting societal values rather than technological imperatives.
When YouTube launched, it wasn’t reinventing entertainment but digitizing a familiar concept. From comedy sketches to music videos, the platform’s content mirrored vaudeville’s varied acts. Similarly, adult-oriented platforms built on user-generated content reflect society's demand for personalized, provocative material, echoing vaudeville’s “blue” acts. The continuity is clear: technology evolves, but cultural needs remain consistent.
Impact on Performers and Audiences
Vaudeville and YouTube both democratized content creation, offering a stage to diverse voices. Anyone with an internet connection can become a YouTube creator, echoing vaudeville’s inclusivity. Amanda Lotz highlights how digital platforms have transformed accessibility, while Lisa Gitelman discusses shifts in legitimacy, showing how cultural forces continue to shape who gets to be a creator.
Audience feedback was vital for vaudeville performers, and it’s just as crucial for YouTube creators today. Metrics like views and likes are modern versions of audience reactions, shaping content just as cheers or boos once did. AI algorithms on YouTube now take on this role, adapting content recommendations to keep us engaged. Have you ever thought about how personalized your YouTube recommendations feel? That’s not magic; it’s AI using data to predict what you’ll enjoy next, just as vaudeville acts could adapt in real time.
And so, influencers are today’s vaudeville stars, curating content and maintaining engagement to captivate their audiences. Monetization strategies have evolved significantly, reflecting the ways creators now generate income through sponsorships, ads, and brand partnerships. Yet, the economic practices driving this influencer economy remain deeply rooted in cultural values, demonstrating that while the platforms may change, the underlying principles of engaging and profiting from an audience have a long-standing history.
The Attention Economy and Cultural Impact
Vaudeville performers competed fiercely for the attention of their audiences, and today’s YouTube creators find themselves in a similar battle. Digital platforms have intensified this competition, making it more dynamic and immediate. The content strategies we see on platforms like YouTube feel familiar because they’re adaptations of longstanding practices—just with the added power of algorithms. Have you ever noticed how quickly your attention can shift from one piece of content to the next online? This isn’t new; it’s the same attention economy that vaudeville thrived in, now transformed for the digital age.
Conclusion
Reflecting on this journey from vaudeville to YouTube and now to AI, one thing becomes clear: technological advancements are rarely as revolutionary as they seem. Instead, they are evolutions built on a foundation of cultural practices that have endured and adapted over time. YouTube’s diverse and engaging content is not a break from the past but a continuation of a historical spirit, reinvented for the digital age. Similarly, AI represents the latest chapter in this ongoing story, designed to fulfill our cultural desire for immediacy, personalization, and variety.

