Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Darren Cross's avatar

Love this piece, Andy—sharp and incredibly insightful. The through-line between AI acceleration, shifting formats, and platform power really lands.

On YouTube, though, I don’t see this as an AI story so much as a platform power story. The click-through T&Cs have always given YouTube broad rights over creator content—but now they’re leaning harder into those rights and showing it. The auto-edited Shorts tests make that clear: the platform decides what gets trimmed, highlighted, or repackaged to serve engagement models, often without meaningful creator input.

That’s not about summarization—it’s about whose version of the work gets prioritized. Platforms have always had this control; what’s new is how openly they’re exercising it.

Expand full comment
Marcelo Guerra's avatar

The analysis is notable for how it connects the panic in Silicon Valley, Netflix's guidelines, and YouTube's moves. The perception that the "algorithm acts as an editor" and redefines content creation is a central point.

The argument that "who defines the format, defines the agency" is a concise and insightful summary of the ongoing shift. The way the article connects these points shows a deep understanding of the situation.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts